Step-by-Step Guide to Parental Alienation
Step-by-Step Guide to Parental Alienation
Often the best way to illustrate how something works is through a little play acting.
People often ask how parental alienation happens in practice. It’s actually fairly easy. Attorney, mediator, and therapist Bill Eddy once illustrated how it works using a fictional trip to the dentist by mother and child.
In each of the following steps, you must only imbue the situation with loads of emotions, allow the child an unnatural level of autonomy, and replace “dentist” with “other parent.” Parental alienation illustrated in 10 easy steps.
You: "Johnny, it's time to go to the dentist. Put your jacket on and get in the car."
Johnny: “No! I won’t go. I refuse to see the dentist.”
1. SOUND ANXIOUS AND MISTRUSTFUL
You (concerned tone of voice and pained facial expression): “Why? Did the dentist ever hurt you?”
Johnny: “Yes! She made me open my mouth when I didn’t want to. She brushed my teeth so hard my gums bled a little. She gave me a shot and pulled out a tooth. It felt sore for a couple days. That’s why I don’t want to go!”
You (very concerned now): “And did anything else happen?”
Johnny (irritated): “No. What do you mean? Isn’t that enough?”
2. MAKE IT INTO A NEGOTIABLE ISSUE
You (very concerned tone of voice): “Why, that’s awful! I didn’t realize that!”
Johnny: “Yes. Please don’t make me go.”
You (looking very ambivalent): “Well, I’m not sure.”
Johnny (now in tears): “Please, please don’t make me go!”
3. USE THE WORD “FORCE” TO HELP BUILD RESISTANCE
You: “Now, now, Johnny. Don’t worry. I can’t force you to go. In fact, I won’t force you to go!”
Johnny: “Thank you, thank you so much. You’re the only one who really understands me and cares.”
4. SEEK OFFICIAL PERMISSION TO SAY CHILD DOESN’T HAVE TO GO
You: “Well, you know the school requires that you see a dentist once a year. I’ll talk to the principal and try to get an exception for you. First, I’ll need to talk to an attorney to get help in persuading the principal.”
Johnny: “Thanks! I feel better already, knowing that you are helping me fight against having to go to the dentist. I knew there was something wrong with that idea.”
5. ASK AN ATTORNEY TO HELP YOU ADVOCATE FOR AN EXCEPTION
Attorney: “Well, I imagine the principal won’t make an exception, unless the situation is really, really bad.”
You: “Oh, let me assure you that Johnny feels really, really strongly about this. We’ve talked about this several times, and now he cries and kicks and screams and locks himself in his room when I talk about it.”
Attorney: “Oh, okay. Well, let me write down everything you have observed about Johnny’s resistant behavior. We’ll submit this to the principal.”
6. GET AN ATTORNEY APPOINTED FOR THE CHILD
Principal (to you and your attorney): “You know, I’m really concerned about how upset Johnny seems to be. On the other hand, Johnny really needs to see a dentist once a year in order to have healthy teeth. You know what, I am going to appoint an attorney for Johnny to see if this is really what Johnny wants and to assess whether he is mature enough to make such a decision.”
Attorney for the child (to Johnny): “Wow. You really are frightened and angry about seeing the dentist. I’m going to recommend that you see a therapist. When the therapist recommends that you’re ready to see the dentist, then I’ll recommend to the principal that you should go. Until then, I’ll recommend that you don’t have to go.”
7. GET AN INDIVIDUAL THERAPIST FOR THE CHILD FOR A YEAR
Therapist for the child (to himself): “At the start, I know I have to develop a therapeutic alliance with Johnny by agreeing with his resistance to seeing the dentist. I will slowly turn him around.”
Therapist for the child (to Johnny, after a year): “I’ve worked with you for a year now, to help you overcome your fear and anger at the dentist by discussing these emotions a lot. Now your attorney, the principal, and your parent want to know if you’re ready to see the dentist yet. What do you think?”
Johnny: “Please, please, please, don’t make me go. You promised me at our first session that you wouldn’t force me to go. Now I feel it more strongly than ever! You have to keep your promise!”
Therapist for the child: “Oh, don’t worry. You know I won’t force you to go. I’ll try to talk your parent out of pressuring you to go. But I think it would be a good idea for you to meet with a reunification counselor and the dentist. I will help prepare you for that meeting, so that you can feel safe.”
8. HAVE CHILD MEET WITH A REUNIFICATION COUNSELOR AND THE DENTIST*
Reunification Counselor: “Now Johnny, please tell the dentist why you don’t want to see her. My job is to help you feel comfortable with the dentist. I won’t force you to actually go to the dentist’s office until you are ready. In the meantime, I want to help you talk to each other. Tell the dentist why you don’t want to see her.”
Johnny (eyes to the ground, speaking softly): “You ruined my life. I have been fearful ever since I last saw you.”
Dentist: “Thank you Johnny for telling me how upset you are. Can you be more specific about what I did. I’d really like to know.”
Johnny (angrily): “You made my gums bleed a little! You gave me a shot I didn’t want! You pulled one of my baby teeth!”
Dentist: “Thank you for telling me that. I can understand how upsetting that must have been for you. However, that’s my job. While it hurts and bleeds briefly, it’s so that you can have healthy teeth for the rest of your life.”
Johnny (sullen): “I still don’t want to see you.” [*Resist any efforts to have YOU meet with Johnny in counseling. Since it’s all the dentist’s fault, any counseling with you would only reinforce the idea that it wasn’t all the dentist’s fault. Plus, everyone knows they can’t force you to do anything anyway.]
9. ENCOURAGE EVERYONE TO ARGUE A LOT OVER WHO’S AT FAULT
You: “It’s all the dentist’s fault that Johnny won’t go. Look at how inappropriate she has been.”
Johnny: “It’s all the dentist’s fault. I hate her.”
Your attorney: “It’s all the dentist’s fault. Johnny shouldn’t have to go.”
The child’s attorney: “It’s in the child’s best interest not to be exposed to this conflict any further. I think he’s mature enough to make this decision now. The dentist can work with him when he’s an adult.”
The child’s therapist: “Johnny just isn’t ready yet. Until the dentist takes full responsibility for her actions and how she has traumatized Johnny, it is unlikely that he will ever be ready. He needs another year.”
10. HAVE EVERYONE GIVE UP
Dentist: “Well, if you really don’t want to see me, I won’t force you. I guess there’s nothing I can do. I won’t even bother you with those little reminder notes every year.”
Reunification Counselor: “Then, I guess there’s nothing that I can do, either.”
Attorney for the child: “And I guess there’s nothing that I can do, either.”
Principal: “And I guess there’s nothing that I can do, either. I’m granting you an exception and I won’t require you to ever have to go to the dentist again.”
You: “What a relief. Now Johnny isn’t anxious anymore and we get along better than ever!”
There you have it: Dental alienation in 10 easy steps! It may be 20 years before this child ever sees a dentist.
Bill Eddy is President of High Conflict Institute and author of Don’t Alienate the Kids! Raising Resilient Children While Avoiding High Conflict Divorce.
High Conflict Institute provides training and consultations regarding High Conflict People (HCPs) to individuals and professionals dealing with legal, workplace, educational, and healthcare disputes.
The mother seriously injures the child. The father takes the child for medical attention, the court puts an order in place so that the father cant take the child for any more medical attention or treatment. The court then accuses the father of trying to alienate the child from the mother. The court gives the mother full sole custody and the father a no contact order.